#78: OT and Habits with Zipporah Brown

Take the Quiz to get 1 CEU

Listen: Apple | Spotify | YouTube
Full Course Details: Public course page
Learn more about our guest: Dr. Zipporah Brown, OTD, MS, OTR/L, DipACLM

:white_check_mark: Agenda

Breakdown and analysis of journal article (5 minutes)
00:00:00 Intro
00:03:07 Background on OT, habits, and health promotion
00:05:36 Why this scoping review is needed
00:06:43 Purpose of this paper
00:07:01 Methods
00:07:42 Results
00:09:41 Article Discussion and Conclusion

Discussion on practical implications for OTs (50 minutes)

00:11:26 Intro to Zipporah Brown
00:14:52 How Zipporah became interested in habits
00:18:33 How habits intersected with Lifestyle Medicine
00:22:19 Article impressions
00:27:30 Environmental modification and habit change
00:31:38 Communicating the power of habit change
00:35:04 Setting habit-based goals
00:39:04 Impactful interventions for habit change
00:49:44 How habit change can advance our profession
00:56:25 Habit change in practice and curriculums

:white_check_mark: Supplemental Resources

:white_check_mark: Article Review

Read Full Text: Habits and Health Promotion in Occupational Therapy: A Scoping Review
Journal: Annals of International Occupational Therapy
Year Published: 2021

How many times have you had to explain what occupational therapists do?

Unfortunately, efforts to help the public understand the power of OT simply have not been as successful as we would like.

But, perhaps the growing public consciousness around the power (and difficulty) of habit change offers a unique opportunity for us to clearly communicate how we can help people change their habits to change their health.

Emphasizing our role as habit change agents has multiple upsides:

:white_check_mark: It differentiates us from our rehab colleagues.
:white_check_mark: It positions us as leaders in caring for those with chronic conditions.
:white_check_mark: It captures the long-term impact of our care.
:white_check_mark: It highlights the skill and necessity of OT.
:white_check_mark: It naturally connects our work to system-level change.
:white_check_mark: It allows us to draw on important research from adjacent fields like psychology.

And, as we’ll see in this week’s scoping review on OT and habit change/health promotion, we’ve been addressing habits since 1912! It’s also a core part of our 2020 practice framework and is increasingly embedded in OT research.

(I should say that weaving this language into our marketing messaging is not the focus of this article—that passion is all my own.) :slight_smile:

Next week on the OT Potential Podcast, we’ll welcome Dr. Zipporah Brown. She and I will discuss ways you can embed best practices around habit change in your OT practice.

Let’s dive in.

Background on OT, Habits, and Health Promotion

As noted in the OT Practice Framework, habits are central to the domain and scope of occupational therapy. They are one of the framework’s 4 outlined performance patterns, along with routines, roles, and rituals.

According to the World Health Organization, health promotion enables people to increase control over their own health. This effort covers a wide range of social and environmental interventions designed to benefit and protect individual health and quality of life by addressing and preventing the root causes of ill health—rather than focusing solely on treatment and cure.

There’s a natural intersection between habits, health promotion, and OT—as occupational therapists are uniquely trained to evaluate and change the very contexts in which habits exist. They play a role in health promotion by encouraging engagement in the healthy habits and routines that facilitate optimal health.

A note on the difficulty of habit change

While changing habits to promote health sounds relatively simple, the reality is that habits are notoriously resistant to change. Goals and good intentions often are not enough to change a habit. Because habits are typically tied to environmental and contextual cues, we need evidence-based interventions to promote habit change.

Habit theory with occupation

Habit change has been a central concept of occupational therapy throughout the history of the field. Dating back to 1912, habit training was established as a form of rehab intended to retrain individuals in activities of daily living and instill habits linked to meaningful occupation.

One of occupational therapy’s most popular theories, MOHO (The Model of Human Occupation), which linked habits to the environment, was originally published in 1980—foreshadowing the popular science around habits.

A broad overview of habit theory in OT includes two key themes:

  1. Habits are often understood as a subset of routine, which in turn constitutes an occupation.
  2. Habits are often influenced, or even triggered, by the context with which they occur.

Why this scoping review is needed now

While habit change has long been a part of OT practice and theory, our expertise in habits is needed now more than ever.

Poor habits are inflicting unprecedented harm on global society, with 80% of deaths now attributed to 4 main disease categories that are linked to lifestyle habits:

  1. Cardiovascular disease
  2. Cancer
  3. Respiratory disease
  4. Diabetes

Conversely, a recent study projected a lifespan increase of 12–14 years in individuals who maintain these 5 healthy habits:

  1. Not smoking
  2. Keeping a healthy body mass index
  3. Participating in regular physical activity
  4. Having low alcohol consumption
  5. Having good nutrition

With global health heavily dependent on good habits—and given the difficulty of modifying habits—our expertise as OTs is more needed than ever before, which leads us to the purpose of this study…

What was the intent of this research?

The intent of this research was to map occupational therapy literature related to the role of habits in health promotion, with a goal of shaping future occupational therapy research and practice.

Methods

This article was scoping review, the protocol for which was assembled by the first author, Erin Epley, as she worked toward her post-professional OTD. (See her capstone project in our Capstone Catalog!)

Studies were included in the review if they:

  • Focused on prevention, health promotion, or wellness.
  • Had the implicit or explicit definition of “habit” as a behavior cued by a situation, context, or environment.
  • Addressed habits with particular relevance to occupational therapy.

Results

The review included 20 articles: 13 empirical studies and 7 non-empirical studies.

All 20 articles were published between 2008 and 2020, with 16 written after 2014. 18 of the articles originated in the United states. 1 was from Australia, and 1 was from Denmark.

Empirical Sources

Here are some specific highlights and strategies from the articles:

This article featured the habit module, “pick two to stick to,” which used habit change techniques such as goal-setting, action-planning, self-monitoring, and motivational interviewing to help change habits for adults with metabolic syndrome.

This article used motivational interviewing and education to help adults prevent progression to fragility.

This article showcased a study on the effects of goal setting and accountability partners among college students.

This study and this study featured community-based programs that worked with children and families on practicing routine awareness and embedding healthy behaviors into occupations.

Lastly, this study employed the REAL Diabetes intervention, which uses goal-setting, self-management techniques, and social support.

Non-Empirical Sources

3 non-empirical studies that stood out to me were:

This scoping review of habit interventions, which featured literature from outside the realm of OT.

This article, which advocated for the role of school OTs in promoting healthy habits.

And this article, which discussed the contribution of occupational science to healthy lifestyle changes through the pursuit of occupation.

Discussion

There has been a recent focus on habits in OT literature, especially since 2014.

The 6 empirical studies and 3 non-empirical studies noted the unique training that OTs have in environmental modification as a strength in their support of habit formation and change.

2 empirical studies mentioned the importance of embedding healthy habits within overarching routines—another strategy in which OTs are uniquely skilled.

As this was a scoping review, the efficacy of different habit change strategies was not explored. But, the strategies identified included:

  • Action-planning,
  • behavior practice and rehearsal,
  • client education,
  • goal-setting,
  • motivational interviewing,
  • peer/family support,
  • problem solving,
  • providing information on consequences, and
  • self-monitoring.

Key implications for practice

Occupational therapy professionals should use their knowledge and expertise in environmental supports, barriers, and modifications to foster positive habit formation and change, ultimately promoting health for their clients.

And, given the importance of routine in supporting habit formation and retention, OT clinicians should assess routines and help their clients embed new habits into their existing routines.

Ep78-AOTA-Badge

:white_check_mark: Review %open%

After earning your certificate, please consider taking a moment to answer the following three questions:

1.) On a scale of 1-5 please indicate the degree to which the learning objectives were met.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
0 voters

2.) Please rate our instructors on a scale of 1-5.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
0 voters

3.) On a scale of 1-5, please rate the learning environment of the Club.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
0 voters

Please share any other feedback below! Including, ideas for future programming, and most importantly, how you feel this podcast will impact your practice!

Good morning, @ErinEpley!! I wanted to be the first to comment since i love this topic so much! I remember reading Atomic Habits when it came out and the whole time thinking, THIS IS SO OT!!

I recently started reading Tiny Habits as well! Are there other books/resources like this you would recommend, or are these the go-tos?

3 Likes

Good morning, Sarah! And what a beautiful synopsis of the scoping review you have done! You have captured the work perfectly. We definitely share the same passion for habits, and I can see we both feel that OTs could and should be the go-to habit experts on the team. Habits are one of the human performance patterns within our domain and scope as listed in our practice framework (along with routines, rituals, and roles).

I have not read Tiny Habits yet, but it’s on my list thanks to you! I LOVE Atomic Habits and think it’s one of the greats, but Wendy Wood’s 2018 work, Good Habits, Bad Habits (though less marketed) is absolutely excellent and we can’t forget Charles Duhigg’s Power of Habit that started the habit frenzy back in 2012, well before Atomic Habits came out.

Both of those are must-reads!

2 Likes

This article hits it on the nose why we are unique as a profession. Our goal is function and I believe we are vastly underestimated in terms of our versatility.

4 Likes

Hi Celina and welcome to our community! I couldn’t agree with you more - we are most definitely under-utilized. We also work within a healthcare system that values medication more than lifestyle change. But we can change that! It can start with small steps like talking to our patients about their habits and seeing if they are ready to make a change (a la motivational interviewing). Then, we can begin to make suggestions to support that. There is much work to be done, but OTs can pave the way!

2 Likes

Thank you so much for the article but can you give more examples of how the environment modification is a support of habit formation and change?

2 Likes

Hi Hanna! That’s a great question, thank you for asking. Research shows that habits are bound to environmental cues. As OTs, environmental analysis is something we are experts at! Essentially, you work with the client to structure the environment so it cues them to perform the habit. One example might be helping a client place their morning medicine at a place they will see it every day and remember to take it. Or, you might suggest someone put their medicine at the breakfast table, or next to their toothbrush. If you are trying to promote exercise for health management, you might suggest a client put sneakers by the door to cue them to take a walk or help them foster a social connection or a walking buddy they meet on a regular basis. Still another example might be to help someone arrange their kitchen so that healthy foods are visually evident and physically easier to grab than unhealthy foods, which you might place in high cabinets or at the back of a cabinet. Hopefully those examples show the environmental component of habit change!

2 Likes

Yes! Understanding this research has made the biggest difference in my personal life!

I now just assume my individual will power will fail :joy:, and focus on structuring my environment!

I put fruit on the middle of my table!
I keep my phone out of my bedroom.
I just don’t buy alcohol for my home.

The changes can seem so small but they are so powerful!

3 Likes

Wow, that 12-14 years of extended lifespan is such a powerful indicator of the importance of health promoting habits and routines! And I agree, OTs are perfectly positioned to facilitate the often tricky task of habit change.

I had the privilege of participating in a modified version of Beth Larson’s Living Well course in OT school, and I still use many of these strategies to help me maintain my own healthy habits!

Question for you, @ErinEpley: How well do you think the research on habit change strategies generalizes to pediatric populations? This seems like a big area of opportunity for these foundational skills to promote health across their lifespans. Are there unique cognitive or psychological considerations for promoting healthy routines among younger children, or is this an area we need more research on?

2 Likes

I do the exact same, Sarah! Willpower is no one’s friend in the battle of habits (research actually shows this too). We have to set our environments up for success!

1 Like

Hi Alana, I absolutely love the work Larson has done and one of her articles appeared in my scoping review! I was able to attend a panel at AOTA Kansas where she and several colleagues spoke about the amazing wellness work they are doing at UW Madison - very impressive!

I am not entirely sure what the state of literature is on cultivating or changing habits in children. I’ll go out on a limb and guess that there isn’t much. My clinical work in schools and pediatric clinic has shown me that children are very cue-driven and I do feel that environmental analysis and adaptation is also a powerful way to support good habits in children. Things like making sure students have access to seating that supports good posture for writing, having shortened writing and coloring tools available for preschoolers (to facilitate functional grasp), and removing tempting or distracting items from an environment to promote attention or discourage engagement in less-preferred activities are powerful tools with the pediatric population.

1 Like

I love this episode! It was great to hear some tangible and evidence-based strategies for problem solving barriers to habit change. I just finished a course in which I was the only OT among other health professionals. During the course, we discussed stages of change end it was great to see the shared language being used in relation to OT. Dr. Brown’s work is so inspiring and I really appreciated her insight.

2 Likes

Awesome discussion, @SarahLyon and @zipporah ! OT and habits go hand in hand. Our models, approaches, and frames of reference in OT practice give us so much room to influence the client and their environment. Advocacy in OT remains an important piece we can not afford to ignore!

1 Like

I’m so happy you listened to this, @Perpetua! I think about this episode ALOT and always feel like as OTs we should be talking about habits more… I think it capture what we do in langauage that people understand!

Do you feel the same way, from your vantage point in Kenya?

I couldn’t agree more @Perpetua ! We are uniquely trained and equipped to support individuals, groups, and communities. Advocacy is SO important, especially thinking about increasing access to healthy lifestyle factors that impact our habits. So glad you enjoyed the episode and I appreciate your insight. Like @SarahLyon, I’m also curious to know more about your experience with this in Kenya.

@ErinEpley your scoping review has been such a helpful resource! I have added it as a reading in my course and referenced it in a publication I’m working on. SO GOOD!

@caitlin15 thank you for your kind sentiments Caitlin! If you don’t mind me asking, what course did you take?

1 Like

Thank you Zipporah and I apologize for my delayed reply. Your interview was amazing and you really highlighted practical application of the work - so glad Sarah invited you on! I love that you’re able to use the article in your teaching too. Let’s keep the work moving forward! OT to the rescue in health promotion!

1 Like

@zipporah Thank you for your work in bringing this practical and often overlooked approach to improved function. I was especially interested to hear you note that as the ACOTE standards are broad, if working in education, we have the ability to incorporate this into academic curricula. I recently finished a PPOTD and I was fortunate to be able to choose a concentration. I chose Health and Wellness Coaching and so was taught in depth about behavior change and motivational interviewing. Although I have yet to sit for the board certification exam, I already practice coaching with my clients. I work clinically in peds and use these strategies with parents to promote carryover and adherence to home programs. I am also OT faculty at the University of Scranton and have incorporated MI, coaching, and habit training into a graduate level class using the Acote Standards B.4.1 (Therapeutic Use of Self) and B4.21 (Teaching Learning Process and Health Literacy). And the students will be listening to this podcast and reading the article for homework! Thank you @SarahLyon for as usual hitting on great topics and @ErinEpley for producing the research!

3 Likes